This is reprinted in its entirety with the permission of its author, Peter Mulcahy. Added to the original article published online were some pictures and the footnotes. The added pictures include the 1783 proclamation and the pictures of the graves. Thank you Peter.
|July 26, 1783 Proclamation:|
The Doan family first came to America in 1629 and branches of it sprang up throughout Cape Cod, Massachusetts.
By 1696 the first of the Doans had moved into Bucks County from Sandwich, Massachusetts and prior to 1726 Israel Doan, the grandfather of the infamous Doan Boys, was squatting on Indian land in Plumstead. At the time this area was deeply forested with great distances between cleared farms. Settlers found the Indians who frequented the area friendly for the most part and there was an abundance of deer and bear to hunt. Bread was made from the Indian corn and when grain was carried to market it was done on long caravans of horses tied head to tail which snaked through the trees on the Indian paths that crisscrossed the area. Men dressed in deerskins and women wore linsey and linen. Every month they would attend the Friends Meeting with the men carrying their weapons because of the strong likelihood of encountering a wolf or bear along the way.
Joseph Doan, Sr., the Father of the outlaw Moses, lived on a farm on what is now Route 611 just south of Plumsteadville. He and his wife Hester had the dubious honor of fathering five of the six Doan outlaws: Joseph, Jr., Moses, Aaron, Levi and Mahlon. Abraham, their first cousin, was the sixth member of the band. Although at various times other outlaws and highwaymen joined up with them, these six were largely responsible for what became the Doan legend.
To understand the origin of the myth that has surrounded these men since they first undertook their exploits, it is necessary to read the description of them by their contemporaries. The sons of Joseph Doan and their cousin were all about 6' in height. They had dark brown hair and long Romanesque noses. Moses had an extremely long neck although all had that similar characteristic in lesser degrees. They were considered quite handsome by the women of their day and in a quirk of fate, they all looked so much alike that they were seldom positively identified in court. But their looks were not the only physical characteristic that the men shared. Each Doan had an athletic ability that was second to none. Saturday afternoons it was the custom for young men from miles around to gather and test each other with a variety of feats of strength and agility. Such games as pitching quoits (hurling large iron bullets,), corner ball and jumping the cat preceded wrestling and foot races. As children growing up in Plumstead, the Doans always excelled athletically be it wrestling, running or jumping. Unfortunately, they displayed these talents most often when they bullied the other locals. One of the few young men in the area to stand up to the Doans was William Hart who, in one of Life's inexplicable twists, would prove to be their tenacious foe years later. None the less, the Doans were repeat winners each Saturday in these feats of machismo which was a constant source of envy for most of their male contemporaries. An indication of how well known they were for their athletic prowess was an incident that occurred in Lancaster in 1786 at the height of their notoriety. A group of men were sitting in front of a hotel and challenging one another to a jumping contest (Remember, there was no TV, at the time). One man quickly defeated the others and while he was basking in his victory another man quietly approached the mark and asked to try. While the locals were smirking at the presumptuousness of the stranger, he proceeded to leap more that two feet higher than the newly crowned champion. The onlookers were astonished and the man who had been beaten was so shocked by the height of the jump that he declared the man had to be either the "Devil or a Doan". The stranger immediately left and later the group learned that the challenger was in fact the outlaw, Abraham Doan.
The career of the Doan Outlaws began with Moses Doan who in the Fall of 1770 quarreled with his Father. In his stubbornness, he refused to make peace and left his childhood home. A few days later he saved the family of the young girl he loved from an Indian attack but his subsequent declaration of love for her was rebuffed. There is speculation that these two events turned Moses bitter and set him off on his path to notoriety. His most immediate reaction was to join a small band of local Indians from the Wolf tribe after telling them that he hated the settlers who were inexorably forcing them out and wanted to fight on their side. It is believed that he stayed with them for several months, hunting and engaging in feats of strength with them which he always won. There is no evidence that Moses actually joined his Indian friends in an attack on the settlers. He did, however, let his hair grow down over his shoulders and took on what even his relatives called a "Devilish Look". What this did for Moses psychologically, no one knows but by the next mention of him, he had organized his brothers and gone on his first raid.
Bucks County at this time was primarily made up of Quakers who did not support the coming battle with England.
|Friends Meetinghouse near Gardenville, built in 1752|
The non-violent nature of the Friends was not welcomed by those who wanted to break from Mother England. The self-sufficient, agrarian Quaker farmers were not as dependent on trade and did not share the rebels' anger over the various taxes that King George was imposing on the Colonies. The local Committees of Safety were taxing the farmers to raise money for the people in Massachusetts who were suffering following England's closure of the port of Boston in 1774. There is some evidence that Moses Doan believed that if the Quakers, including his parents and relatives, did not pay this tax, they would be branded traitors and their lands would be confiscated by the American government. Whether or not this was true, Moses used this information to sway his brothers into fighting with him for the British and against the rebels. It is generally agreed that by 1774 Moses had enlisted his brothers, Aaron, Levi, Mahlon and Joseph and his cousin Abraham to his cause. It was Moses' idea to harass the Colonists and take back the tribute exacted from their own families by robbing the tax collectors. Unfortunately, while Moses rode to Newtown to scout out the strength and location of the rebels, his newly founded band got antsy and decided to break the ice on their new career by crossing into New Jersey and robbing Mary Doremy's father, the woman who months earlier had turned down Moses' offer of love.
What followed was the stuff of which legends are made.
Having returned late from Newtown, Moses learned of the raid and rode to New Jersey in time to find his brothers in the process of beating the old man into telling them where his gold was hidden. After stopping his overeager band, he promised Mary that although they would never have a life together he would always protect her and her family; and they would never need fear him nor his brothers.
|Half Moon Inn, built in 1733|
Later that evening Moses unveiled to his followers what their principal source of income would prove to be for several years: stealing horses in Bucks County, driving them into Philadelphia and selling them to the British. That and the periodic robbery of Whig tax collectors and wealthy Whig citizens became the modus operandi of the Doans. Yet even in their thievery they held to a strange sense of humor. The horse of Joseph Sackett, was stolen by the Doans three different times, keeping it for their own use for nine months the first time and for three months the second. Each time when they no longer needed the horse, they returned it at night to Sackett's pasture. Years later in Canada, Joseph Doan said that they had stolen Sackett's horse for the pure fun of it and did so only to let him and his neighbors know that it could be done. In fact, the surest way to be robbed by the Doans was to let it pass at the local tavern that you were too well protected to ever become their victim. [Historical accounts list the total number of horses stolen from their neighbors at 200.]
There were other well-publicized actions during this time that clouded the outlaw name that had been branded on the Doans. Their raid in Chester county on Israel Lucas, for example, clearly showed the limits of Moses' debauchery. During the raid, a sleazy ne'er-do-well by the name of Foxy Joe who had recently joined their group, beat Lucas senseless and then made advances towards his young wife. When Moses Doan entered the room he struck Foxy Joe and made it quite clear that such behavior would not be tolerated. Later that evening when Foxy tried to renew his interest in the woman, Moses beat him near death and then threw him down the stairwell. Returning to the man they were robbing he apologized for Foxy's actions.
At this point in their careers the Doans were working regularly for the British Army as spies and horse "Suppliers". Their cleverness with disguises and their knowledge of the local area allowed them to stay close to the rebel encampments and pass information on troop movements to the British. Their close association with the English began in July of 1776, when Moses and Levi Doan rode to Staten Island, New York to meet with General Howe. He offered himself and his men into the service of the Crown as spies and they were immediately accepted. Their first mission was to spy on the rebel encampments at Newark and Long Island until reinforcements arrived from England and Howe could move on them. While Moses occupied himself primarily with the daily duties of spying, the others went on raiding parties and robbed local Whigs. Many stories began to circulate at this time about Moses' reckless courage since he would ride up to a rebel guard post in the middle of the night, wave hello and then ride off into the darkness on his coal-black horse. His bravado earned him invaluable information for Howe and a reputation as a supernatural being. His reports to the General were so precise and detailed that Howe nicknamed him "Eagle Spy". The ensuing defeat of Washington's army on Long Island was directly attributed to Moses Doan who discovered an unprotected backway into the American fortifications. The success of the attack left Long Island in the hands of the British and sent Washington retreating down through New Jersey and into Pennsylvania.
Following that battle, Moses returned to Bucks County to join up with his band who had been driven out of New Jersey by the hue and cry over their activities. They stayed in the home of a friend on Jericho Mountain leaving just before Christmas 1776 to stay close to the Rebel army that was encamped along the river near Newtown. Since they were known on sight by most of the locals, the Doans slept in caves in Solebury and Buckingham during the day and did their spying at night. One of these caves is located in Center Bridge and was discovered in 1875.
Doan and the British suspected that Washington might attack Trenton but they had no idea when, and felt confident that the British and the Hession reinforcements there would prevail. Moses and Abraham were in Newtown on Christmas Eve day and noticed that preparations were underway for marching the troops. They also noticed ferry barges assembling near McKonkey's Ferry (Washington's Crossing, PA). Actually, in the weeks prior, General Washington had ordered that all the boats North and South of the ferry to be confiscated for their use or destroyed. Moses sent Levi with this news to General Grant via New Brunswick and then returned to his Jericho Mountain cave and planned to scout the rebels the following day. That morning he disguised himself as a local farmer and took Old York Road. towards New Hope. He passed the Buckingham Friends and eventually took the Ferry Road to Coryell's Ferry. It was here that Moses saw that the troops and usual sentinels were gone and preparations were being made to dismantle the fortifications. He rode to Bowman's hill where the main rebel encampment was and realized that something very big was happening. At this time a Nor'easter had begun to blow and sleet and snow were falling. Moses suspected that the rebels were heading for Trenton and knew his only chance to help the British was to warn them himself. He went north past Coryell's to Howell's Ferry which was run by a loyal Tory. There he crossed the ice choked river in what had become a raging storm.. Securing a horse, he rode south into the near blizzard. The howling wind, the pounding of the river and cracking of the ice floes was incredible as was the near zero temperature but he kept on. He encountered no one on the road and considered turning back, thinking he may have been wrong about the Americans' intentions.
In an incredible historic moment, as he passed the embankment across from McKonkey's (now Washington Crossing), he heard and saw the rebel barges filled with soldiers pushing through the blizzard towards the Jersey side. He was now sure that their objective was Trenton. Moses Doan was, at that moment, in possession of one of the greatest secrets of the war.
There are several versions of what happened next. Historians agree that Moses made it to Trenton and requested to see Colonel Rahl who was in command. The Colonel was playing cards and reportedly did not want to be disturbed. Moses wrote a note and asked that it be immediately brought to Rahl who simply put it into his vest pocket unread. It was found on his person the next day. The note read: "Washington is coming on you down the river, he will be here afore long. Doan". The versions differ mainly on how and from whom Rahl got the note. Most historians agree that a more attentive commander may have utilized Moses Doan's note to prevent one of the Colonial Army's greatest moral victories, perhaps ringing the death knell to the Colonial's dreams.
DOAN, The Liberator
|The Doan Gang Roadside Marker in Bucks County at 4914A Point Pleasant Pike, Gardenville, at the Friends Mtg. House, dedicated 11/5/2005 -- "In 1783 the PA State Government declared six Doan family members outlaws for robberies, burglaries, and felonies. During the Revolutionary War, the Doans of Plumstead Twp. spied for and sold stolen horses to the British Army. They robbed the county treasury in 1781. Leader Moses was killed in a shoot-out, Abraham and Levi were hanged, Joseph Jr. and Aaron fled to Canada, and Mahlon disappeared. Three are buried nearby."|
In 1778 following the British victory at Brandywine, the English occupied Philadelphia to the delight of the Doans. It made it much easier for them to sell their plunder and horses in the city. During February of that year their raids throughout Bucks County resulted for the first time in the raising of a posse for the sole purpose of bringing them to justice. At this time an incident occurred which illustrated not only the noble though misguided nature of Moses Doan, but also his capacity for violence.
A young mother whose husband was with Washington at Valley Forge could not obtain a travelling pass from the British in order to buy food for her children. Despite repeated petitions to the British leaders, the pass was not forthcoming. Spurned on by the cries of her hungry children, she finally set out for the mills along a series of back roads that would keep her from the sight of the British sentinels. The woman was so exhausted from hunger and the long journey that she was near death the following day when she endeavored to return home. Burdened by her sack of flour, she struggled along the road, periodically dragging her cargo through the woods to skirt the British guards along the way. Suddenly she was stopped by a man. She immediately assumed from previous descriptions that he was one of the Doans. She told him of her husband at Valley Forge and her hungry children and the stranger, Moses Doan, gave her his purse with all the money he had in it. He then warned her of another sentinel just ahead on the road and disappeared before she could thank him. She pressed on and was almost home when a British guard challenged her and demanded a pass. When she could not produce it, he demanded her sack of flour which the woman, weak from her journey, gave up meekly. At that moment Moses Doan appeared from the woods. She knew it was Moses by his clothing but his demeanor was quite different from the man she had met only minutes before. He shambled over to the soldier like an old man and asked that he return the woman's flour, even offering twice its value in gold. When the guard refused and then threatened to arrest Moses, he seized him by the throat and told the woman to grab her flour and run. As soon as she was safely away, Moses drew a pistol and shot the guard in the head. Instantly, the alarm went up from the guard house and along the line of pickets. Moses escaped into the woods where he found his horse and rode for the safety of the river. Before he was to finally escape he would shoot another guard and kill a British officer who was in the lead barge pursuing him across the Delaware. Having failed to capture him, the British soldiers later attributed his escape to supernatural reasons which served to further escalate the legend of Moses Doan.
|Located on Tohickon Creek, this cave was a favorite hiding place of the Doan gang. Searching for food, it was from here that outlaw leader Moses Doan left on the fateful morning of August 28, 1783, to meet his death at the hands of Robert Gibson.|
On June 7th just south of Elizabethtown, an army of four thousand British soldiers who had marched from Staten Island to attack a small settlement on the strength of a report by Moses Doan that the citizens were sympathizers to the rebel cause. Moses did not know this, he simply ascertained that there were wealthy farmers in the settlement and tricked the British into attacking so his men could take the plunder. During the attack, an intoxicated Abraham Doan killed the local Pastor's wife, a mother of nine, as she sat in her home with her children huddled in fear around her. With that crime the Doans crossed a line from which they were never able to return. Within three years their leader would be dead and the others in jail or being pursued unmercifully.
Still their legend grew in all directions. Later that year it became known that Joseph Doan had impersonated the British Lord Rawdon who during the English occupation of Philadelphia was a popular guest at the homes of both Tories and Whigs. For two days this Plumstead farm boy who possessed a striking resemblance to the English Lord, impersonated him while a guest of one of Philadelphia's most distinguished families. He was later described as witty and charming although, in the end, he had relieved his host of his cash and much of his silverware. Several days later, Doan mailed his victim a letter asking if he enjoyed his visit with Lord Rawdon.
The following year, October 22, 1781 the Doans robbed the Newtown Treasury of 1,307 Pounds, the largest robbery of Public funds ever. It is believed they did this in retaliation for the surrender of Cornwallis at Yorktown three days earlier. Newtown at the time was a mustering center for the Colonial Army.. the Doans' incredible bravado had to be the result of the impunity they had operated with since their first raid. From eyewitness testimony, it is believed that the outlaws fled into Wrightstown where they buried the money... it was never found.
That winter they began stealing horses again and running them south to Baltimore for sale. A neighborhood defense group was organized to put an end to their raids but many of the locals refused to help fearing that, if unsuccessful, the Doans would come down hard on them. Colonel William Hart, a Doan adversary from his childhood years with them, enlisted the aid of twelve other men including a Colonel Robinson who was running a popular tavern in Dublin at the time. Also on the posse was Patrick Mechlin who proved to be a rather large thorn in the Doans' side. His was the job of spying on the outlaws activities and he did so with such determination that he would sleep all day and prowl all night in search of them. He rode a horse faster than any ridden by the outlaws and he had a habit of catching them on the road, riding ahead and screaming, "The Doans are Coming, The Doans are Coming". Needless to say, this thwarted many of the outlaws' intentions.
At this time Colonel George Piper of Bedminster was appointed deputy U.S. Marshal with authority to arrest the Doans dead or alive [not true - see footnote]. He and his posse commitatus made it very difficult for the Doans, nearly capturing them on several occasions and rooting out their secret rooms and hiding places in area barns. Colonel Hart's tenacity forced the Doans south into Virginia and they stayed away from Bucks County for more than a year. During that time, one of the gang's number, James Fitzpatrick of Chester County, who had decided not to go South with them, was captured, tried and hung in Philadelphia. Fitzpatrick, a well known Chester County outlaw, had joined the Doans and became a close friend of Moses. His execution had a profound effect on the gang's leader who, uncharacteristically and unsuccessfully tried to murder the woman who had betrayed Fitzpatrick to the rebels. He informed his gang that from then on they could expect the same treatment from the authorities if they were captured.
From this point on the Doans were trailed incessantly by a variety of armed posses. With the war over, they could no longer count on the help of Loyalists. Worse, they could not return home literally since the government had confiscated the properties of their parents in punishment for their children's actions. Yet with all the pressures on them, they returned to the Plumstead area and began robbing the local farmers once again.
Some time later during an attempted robbery at Colonel Robinson's tavern in Dublin, Joseph Doan was shot and captured. He was immediately transferred into Philadelphia and imprisoned. Moses and the rest meanwhile were hiding in a small log house along the Tohickon Creek on the Plumstead side. It is this event that led to the legend that Moses Doan rode his horse off the cliffs above Fleecydale Road, choosing death rather than capture at the hands of Colonel Hart's men.
|Fleecydale Road cliffs|
The gang was, in fact, secreted at a farm above Fleecydale Road. It was owned by a man named Halsey who had hidden them on occasion. The man's wife had no flour with which to feed them and she sent her eleven year old son to Wismer's mill located along the Delaware. The boy let it slip that the Doans were at his house and word was passed to Colonel Hart who was drinking at the Gardenville Tavern at the time.
At that moment Abraham and Levi Doan leaped through the back window of the cabin and tried to escape. Abraham used Mrs. Halsey as a shield and was able to get to his horse and flee, while Levi grabbed his rifle and, holding his pursuers at bay, demanded they release Moses. As Moses was already dead, there could be no bargaining and their silence infuriated Levi who took aim and fired. Tragically the musket ball struck the rifle of Colonel Hart's younger brother, splintered the wood and drove a shard of it into Major Kennedy's groin...the Major would die of the wound two days later at the age of forty.
|"Death of Major Kennedy and Moses Doan" -- August 28, 1783 [Note that this drawing is believed by me (DLH) to be inaccurate -- I do not think the posse was dressed in militia garb at the time and I do not think the posse was so large; at the time that Kennedy and Doan were shot I think two posse members were outside at the door and only two inside, with only Moses Doan still in the house while Abraham and Levi were escaping up a ladder and through the loft]|
His funeral, the largest ever held in that area, saw hundreds of local and State military units who had come to pay their respects. The Major was buried with full military honors at the Presbyterian Church in Deep Run where his grave can still be seen today marked with a large white headstone.
The disposition of Moses' body was a different matter. As he lay dead on the steps of the Halsey home, a local man, Philip Hinkle, dragged the body on to his horse and rode with it to Fisherville before anyone could protest. There he came upon Moses' mother and father and dumped the body at their feet crying, "Here is one of your Tory sons. He won't bother any of us soon again."
Moses was interred in a field behind the village of Fisherville in an unmarked grave that has never been found. Seven days following the death of Major Kennedy the Pennsylvania Legislature passed an act designed to bring the Doans to justice. 100 pounds reward was offered for Abraham, Mahlon, Levi and Aaron Doan. Furthermore the family of any citizen killed in an attempt to capture any of the Doans would receive 800 pounds. A month later Mahlon Doan was arrested in Baltimore for stealing horses. He escaped by cutting off the fleshy parts of his heels in order to slip off his iron shackles and although he was tracked by his blood for several miles, he was never found. For years it was believed that he drowned himself in the Chesapeake rather than be captured again but years later, during an interview, the son of outlaw Aaron Doan said that Mahlon escaped to New York where he and other loyalists boarded a boat for England.
On May 15, 1787 Abraham and Levi were arrested in Chester county. Exhausted by years of dogged pursuit, they surrendered without a struggle. They stood trial in Philadelphia, were convicted and taken to Smith's Island and hung on September 24th. True to their legend their days in prison were marked with controversy and several attempted escapes. The controversy centered on the Treaty of Peace signed in 1785 which explicitly protected them from punishment for their actions during the Revolution. Their execution was considered by many to be a gross injustice in light of the treaty. Equally newsworthy were the escape tries which were the work of Mary Doan, Abraham's sister. Her first attempt involved a saw and a file baked into a loaf of bread. Having been discovered and turned away, she returned later that day disguised as an old Quaker woman on her regular visit to the jail. This time she was able to pass a file to her brother. Unfortunately they were hung before they sawed through the bars. Mary Doan pleaded for their bodies and returned home with them to Plumstead where she petitioned the Friends to allow her to bury them in the Meeting House cemetery. The Friends refused and the cousins graves can still be seen outside the far left back wall of the cemetery located on Ferry Road just past the Gardenville Inn.
If you visit it, enter the walled cemetery through the wooden gate in front and walk carefully to the rear left wall. There, if you peek over the wall slowly, you will see the headstones of the two cousins. Do it slowly because legend has it that you should never surprise a Doan whether alive or dead.
Following Levi and Abraham's deaths Aaron and Joseph, Jr. fled to Canada. There is evidence that Joseph, Jr. taught school in Humberstone, Ontario near Niagara Falls and returned to Bucks County to reclaim property in 1820. He later returned to Walpole, Ontario where he lived the remainder of his years. It is believed that Aaron stayed close by and was interred at Humberstone. [Note: this account does not seem to agree with the documents found in the Pennsylvania Archives -- 1783 Aaron Doan was captured in Baltimore, brought to Philadelphia and tried -- see footnotes for document transcriptions.}
Without any doubt The Doans were and have been big news in Bucks County from the moment of their first raid. Periodically the local papers have serialized their life and times which not only spurred newspaper sales but also helped blur much of the evidence concerning their exploits. The first of such stories appeared in the July 1839 issue of Record of the Volunteers of the United States, one of several magazines published between 1830-1840 in the interest of military and naval readers After that, serialized accounts of the Plumstead Cowboys and the Bucks County Bandittories appeared in the Doylestown Democrat, The Democratic Standard, the Doylestown Watchtower and several other publications. The issues of these newspapers that contained material about the Doans were always well received.
The continual re-telling of the Doans' story and the emotions involved in interviewing their aging victims and supporters led to a thick layer of myth that encrusted the facts of their life. The story that Moses Doan rode his horse off the cliffs above Fleecydale Road in order to commit suicide on the trail below is myth. What is fact, however, is that the Doans were a major presence in Carversville during their reign of terror which perhaps accounts for some of the ongoing interest in the Plumstead Cowboys. There are several sources of information on the Doans ranging from The New Doan Book by George MacReynolds to copies of the old newspaper stories available on microfiche at the Spruance Library. In addition, the Mercer Museum has several artifacts including Moses' gun and powder horn.
The more you learn about the Doans and their exploits, the more you will be prepared for that moment when you are walking through the woods on Jericho Mountain or in Northhampton Township or on the hillside above Center Bridge and you hear the ghostly sound of approaching horses in the darkness. Don't panic and run because you may accidentally stumble into one of the long lost caves frequented by the Doans. If you do, be sure to take some time and look around before you spread the word. Why? Because that 1,300 pounds sterling from the Newtown Treasury was never recovered.
Footnotes by Donna Hay (DLH):
Errors in above article: George Piper was not a Colonel in 1783; there is no documentation that he even served in any militia during the revolution (1775-1781). He was promoted to Captain of the Militia in 1786, and did serve during the War of 1812. George Piper was also not appointed deputy U.S. Marshal in 1783 -- the Marshal service was not formed until 1789. These errors were based on one or both of the following sources:
• 1897 "The Doan Outlaws; or, Bucks County's Cowboys" by John Pugh -- "Colonel George Piper was appointed a deputy Marshal of the U.S. with authority to arrest the Doans, either dead or alive, and to affix a price upon their heads, to be given to any one who should take them" and then goes on to tell a story about one of Pipers pursuits of the Doans.
• 1971 "Rogues of the revolution: the story of the Doane renegades" by Reed -- "Colonel George Piper of Bedminster was presently appointed Deputy US Marshal for the Bucks County District -- the principal object of his appointment being the elimination of the Doans. Reports of the Doanes' activities were constantly reported to Piper and several of their rendezvous were discovered."
I (DLH) find it fascinating that this story of George Piper being a colonel and of him being a Marshal and of him being instrumental in hunting down the Doan gang is included in these two sources, but that the story of his wife Eve Piper accosting two gang members in their tavern is not. Pugh's book post-dated the 1875 Keachline letter and its 1876 publication in the history book, and he did not mention Eve Piper's fracas or Robert Gibson's gang membership or even hint that he was a Tory sympathiser/spy. The source for his George Piper story is unknown, assumed to be a grandchild/great-grandchild of the Pipers.
Our ancestor Jesse Britton (born 1759) would have known the Doans personally, being their junior by about 5-10 years. It is unknown when Jesse's family moved to Bucks, as he was born in nearby Berks county, but the move was prior to 1775 when Jesse joined the local militia at age 16, at about the time as when the Doan gang first started up. So the Doan spying activities would have personally affected his unit and his family, and not just the "greater cause" in which he fervently believed. While Jesse and his family moved to Frederick, Virginia ~1779 when his brother Joseph signed up to fight, the family visited Bucks often, and for extended periods of time; Jesse's first two children were born in Virginia and the next two in Bucks. And, it is documented that Jesse was in Bucks in the summer of 1783 as a member of the posse who captured Moses Doan, as he was on the list as one of the 13 men claiming the reward, as well as the executor of Captain Robert Gibson's estate in 1787-1788.
After much research, historian Terry McNealy (formerly with the Bucks County Historical Society) concluded that contrary to the SAR/DAR records, it was Robert Gibson Jr (~1750-1787) who was the Captain during the Revolution, and not his father Robert Gibson Sr (although Terry will not specify they are father and son since no specific documentation of this has been found). It was therefore Robert Gibson Jr who was robbed by the Doans in 1783, and the one who shot Moses Doan in 1783, and the one who requested leniency for the Vickers and the Doans in 1782-1784. Terry is in process of writing a book "The Doan Gang; the remarkable history of America's Most Notorious Loyalist Outlaws" (not released yet as of February 2014)
Genealogy: The marriage record for Robert Gibson and Mary Britton in 1775 is assumed to be for Robert Gibson Jr as well; she is assumed to be a sister of Jesse's. Robert's sister Mary married a Britton, assumed to be a brother of Jesse's. Jesse's wife Anna Gibson is thought to be some relation, perhaps a cousin. The Joseph Britton who served as co-executor of Robert Gibson's Sr's estate in 1788 is thought to be Jesse's father. (These are the usual conclusions made in genealogy when there is only one Gibson family in Plumstead.) And an interesting tidbit is that after Robert Gibson Sr's wife died, he married the widow Elizabeth Keith, in whose home General Washington had resided for 10 days prior to the crossing of the Delaware; and it was here that he read Thomas Payne's moving words "these are the times that try men's souls...."
As Wikipedia says, "The Doans were polarizing figures. Loyalists wrote of the Doan gang as if they were Robin Hood. Patriots referred to them as demons." I (DLH) have found that many of the articles of the day are less than factual; it seems that all nefarious deeds near and far are attributed to Doan gang members. And there are some incredibly knight-like positive stories (e.g., the account of the killing of a British officer to help a damsel in distress). Neither the positive nor negative accounts give an accurate overview of the matter, and many on both sides have no corroboration or even have been discounted by other reliable sources (e.g., the account of Abraham Doan killing a pastor's wife in front of her nine children -- the woman's husband stated it was a British soldier). It is safe to say that at the beginning of the war they mostly stole horses from their neighbors to sell to the British for personal gain; toward the end of the war and for two years after the end of the war they ramped up their outlaw ways to rob from their neighbors at night, in their homes, often waking them from their beds, and terrorizing the families and threatening harm and sometimes even committing it. And while the reported crimes were (until 1783) mostly of collectors and the treasury, these monies were in strongboxes in homes and not in banks -- these robberies were undertaken at the men's homes at night with 5-25 robbers breaking down the door, waking and threatening the whole family with guns -- this was not at all like a daytime robbery of a bank.
There is a lot of uncertainty about Moses Doan's killing, as there are no accounts at all by any of the posse or gang members. There were no local newspapers in Bucks in 1783, and the article in the Philadelphia (Pennsylvania Gazette) newspaper does not mention any of the posse by name (other than Major Kennedy who was killed by the Doans) and states that Doan was resisting arrest when shot. Only 60 years later, in the 1840s and 1850s, was there a resurgence of interest, and popular books and Bucks newspaper serial articles fleshed out many details.
The first identification that Gibson was the shooter of Doan was 59 years later, and this source also mentioned that Doan had surrendered, apparently based on the account of the son-in-law of Hart, one of the posse members. But these accounts did not hint at any gang involvement or Tory sympathies on the part of Gibson; the son-in-law simply was relating how his father-in-law had single-handedly rushed in the cabin to confront the outlaws alone (!), fired at them and they at him (this was perhaps when Kennedy was killed) and then overpowered Moses Doan and extracted his surrender.
None of the books or articles of the 1840s-1860s mention Eve Piper's scuffle or Gibson's gang involvement. The first mention of both of these was in a 1875 letter from William Keachline, the grandson of tavern-owner Eve Piper. Until this time, no motive was mentioned for the shooting of Moses Doan; it was likely deemed obvious that the entire posse shot at the gang members on many occasions in an attempt to apprehend them and stop the crime sprees, which seemed to be escalating even two years after the war ended, and were more vicious based on the depositions of the victims of the July 1783 robberies.
My detailed research shows that there is no evidence that Robert Gibson was a gang member or spy or even that Eve Piper ever confronted two Doan outlaws. In fact, Eve Piper could not have confronted Doan gang members in the tavern as they did not own the tavern until 1784, after the shoot-out. Additionally, as Major Kennedy's brother-in-law served as surety to Gibson's estate in 1787, and Hart's son-in-law did not mention it in 1846, it seems certain that the militia did not think of Gibson as a gang-member/secret-Tory either at the time or in the next 60 years. There are 32 known gang members; no Gibson or Geddis. No posse member, mostly militiamen with whom Gibson had served for eight years, ever hinted at any gang membership or Tory leanings. And despite Keachline stating that there was widespread public wrath at Geddis for suing Eve Piper for breaking his arm, there was no mention by anyone in the public in the intervening century, not even in depositions by gang members. Moreover, there is no lawsuit found and the concept that Eve Piper would assault two gang members alone because they ruined her buckwheat is absurd, as is the notion that a criminal wanted dead-or-alive would file a lawsuit.
In Winter 2013-2014, the Bucks County Historical Society published a 500-word article they had invited me to write to try to present the viewpoint that this 140 year rumor was not only unsubstantiated, but also provably false.